Location: Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
+61 [0] 422695171

Differences between the bee types?

We are grateful you are here

Differences between the bee types?

Back when I was first looking into beekeeping, I thought I'd read that the rough breakdown was:
Buckfast:
* super gentle
* Good honey production
* Low cold climate winter survivability
* low disease resistance
Italian:
* Gentle
* Great honey production
* low cold climate winter survivability
* low disease resistance
Carniolan:
* moderately defensive
* good honey production
* moderate cold climate winter survivability
* low disease resistance
Russian:
* defensive
* OK honey production
* high cold climate winter survivability
* moderate disease resistance
Saskatraz:
* defensive
* moderate honey production
* high cold climate winter survivability
* high disease resistance

This is all kind of ignoring VSH variants.

My confusion is someone on here today posted about their saskatraz being super gentle, and then when I was looking that up, I ran across some articles stating carniolan are more gentle than italian, and others saying they're more defensive than italian.

Is the rough outline I put above roughly correct? Do I have something wrong? Is it all just really subjective and more situational where one person's carniolan hive will be more gentle than their italian hive, but a different person will have the opposite experience?

For example, I thought buckfast were supposed to be extremely gentle, but this year my buckfast hive is actually more defensive than my italian hives (that being said, the queen doesn't seem to have a great laying pattern, so I suspect there's something wrong with her and am considering requeening, so maybe the bees in the hive are being affected by a queen that isn't doing so well.)

submitted by /u/loupgarou21
[link] [comments]

 

Please Login to Comment.